Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

A considered choice.
A better ride.

Compare ⇄ ♡ Saved
  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

Circle Y

22 reviews from this brand
Circle Y Reno 2373 review: a comfortable crossover seat, with the delivery details checked
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Reno 2373

a comfortable crossover seat, with the delivery details checked

Read review ↗: Circle Y Reno 2373
Circle Y Salt River 1667 review: close contact with a finish check
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Salt River 1667

close contact with a finish check

Read review ↗: Circle Y Salt River 1667
Circle Y Sheridan 1572 review: compare the fender position before choosing a tree width
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Sheridan 1572

compare the fender position before choosing a tree width

Read review ↗: Circle Y Sheridan 1572
Circle Y Sunflower 1682 review: a deep seat can feel secure or restrictive
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Sunflower 1682

a deep seat can feel secure or restrictive

Read review ↗: Circle Y Sunflower 1682
Circle Y Swift 1522 review: light handling does not settle seat firmness or fender length
Barrel Saddle

Circle Y Swift 1522

light handling does not settle seat firmness or fender length

Read review ↗: Circle Y Swift 1522
Circle Y Topeka 1651 review: long-ride comfort with tree choice still decisive
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Topeka 1651

long-ride comfort with tree choice still decisive

Read review ↗: Circle Y Topeka 1651
Circle Y Virginia 1588 review: check the rigging behind the photograph
Endurance Saddle

Circle Y Virginia 1588

check the rigging behind the photograph

Read review ↗: Circle Y Virginia 1588
Circle Y Walnut Grove 1157 review: does its deep seat leave you enough room?
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Walnut Grove 1157

does its deep seat leave you enough room?

Read review ↗: Circle Y Walnut Grove 1157
Circle Y Wind River 1750 review: a comfortable riding position, a substantial lift
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Wind River 1750

a comfortable riding position, a substantial lift

Read review ↗: Circle Y Wind River 1750
Josey Ultimate Cash MJ79 review: choose the seat configuration
Barrel Saddle

Josey Ultimate Cash MJ79

choose the seat configuration

Read review ↗: Josey Ultimate Cash MJ79
Loading...

EXPLORE THE CATEGORIES

Find your riding style.

From quiet trail miles to a day in the arena.

All saddle reviews ↗
Barrel racing saddles Around the next turn ↗ Endurance saddles For the miles ahead ↗ English saddles Dressage, jumping & all-purpose ↗ Ranch & roping saddles Explore working saddle styles ↗ Reining & training saddles Schooling & arena work ↗ Trail saddles Everyday trails & longer rides ↗
Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

Thoughtful saddle research for the way you ride. Model details, owner perspectives and the questions worth asking before you buy.

Find your saddle

  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

The fine print

  • About the project
  • Contact
  • Affiliate disclosure
  • Privacy policy
© 2026 Saddle Compass

Retailer links may earn us a commission. Owner reports are attributed experiences, not our riding tests.