Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

A considered choice.
A better ride.

Compare ⇄ ♡ Saved
  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

THE REVIEW INDEX

Saddle reviews

Find a model, read the owner evidence and compare its documented specifications.

Compare saddles ↗

Riding style

☷All reviews150 model reviews Western trail saddles72 reviews Barrel racing saddles21 reviews Ranch, roping and all-around saddles21 reviews English saddles15 reviews Reining and training saddles11 reviews Endurance saddles10 reviews
BrandAll brands⌄
Choose brands

150 reviews

Save a model or select two to compare.

American Saddlery Denero 824 / 825 — merchant product photograph

American Saddlery

American Denero

Consider for
Regular riding comfort
  • 25-inch skirt
  • 5-inch cantle
Check before buying
Compare the original skirt with the II.
Read review ↗: American Denero
American Saddlery Antar 915/916 — merchant product photograph

American Saddlery

American Saddlery Antar 915/916

Consider for
Secure Arabian-tree seating
  • 4-inch cantle
  • 25-inch skirt
Check before buying
Actual lifting effort and finish.
Read review ↗: American Saddlery Antar 915/916
American Saddlery The Mule Tamer Saddle 1740 — listing product photograph

American Saddlery

American Saddlery Mule Tamer 1740

Consider for
Leather mule-trail setups
  • Mule bars
  • Brass rigging
Check before buying
Rear skirt-join clearance and seat room.
Read review ↗: American Saddlery Mule Tamer 1740
Arena All Purpose — merchant product photograph

Arena

Arena All Purpose

Consider for
Leather feel and wipe-clean lining
  • Leather upper / technical lining
  • All-purpose riding layout
Check before buying
Mixed construction is a benefit for cleanup and a drawback if all leather is essential.
Read review ↗: Arena All Purpose
Arena Jump — merchant product photograph

Arena

Arena Jump

Consider for
Soft-leather jumping trials
  • Jump-focused layout
  • Movable front and rear blocks
Check before buying
The sole owner reports easy scratching and limited riding time.
Read review ↗: Arena Jump
Arena Wide Dressage — merchant product photograph

Arena

Arena Wide Dressage

Consider for
Wide-horse dressage fitting trials
  • Wide/Cob model family
  • WIDE gullet system on current model
Check before buying
The sole owner liked the horse fit but wanted a deeper-feeling seat.
Read review ↗: Arena Wide Dressage
American Saddlery Austin Arabian II 921 — merchant product photograph

American Saddlery

Austin Arabian II 921

Consider for
High-cantle adjustable girthing
  • 5-inch cantle
  • Padded seat
Check before buying
Tree fit, seat room and supplied straps.
Read review ↗: Austin Arabian II 921
Bates All Purpose SC — merchant product photograph

Bates

Bates All Purpose SC

Consider for
Hacking with an open seat
  • Square cantle and open seat
  • Forward-cut flap
Check before buying
The owner record does not establish advanced jumping performance or long-term wear.
Read review ↗: Bates All Purpose SC
Bates Dressage Heritage CAIR — merchant product photograph

Bates

Bates Dressage

Consider for
Narrow-twist dressage trials
  • Deep seat with narrow waist
  • Adjustable ergonomic stirrup bars listed
Check before buying
The detailed positive account comes from one rider over roughly two months.
Read review ↗: Bates Dressage
1 2 3 … 17 Next →
Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

Thoughtful saddle research for the way you ride. Model details, owner perspectives and the questions worth asking before you buy.

Find your saddle

  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

The fine print

  • About the project
  • Contact
  • Affiliate disclosure
  • Privacy policy
© 2026 Saddle Compass

Retailer links may earn us a commission. Owner reports are attributed experiences, not our riding tests.