Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

A considered choice.
A better ride.

Compare Saved

Saddle comparisons

Look closely at the differences between saddle models before making your choice.

Illustration of a Western saddle and coiled rope on a ranch fence
Big Horn Draft Cross 1680/1682 — merchant product photograph

Big Horn Draft Cross vs Fabtron Draft: broad fit, different rider compromises

Big Horn Gaited 605/606 — merchant product photograph

Big Horn 605/606 vs Fabtron Gaited: the lift is only the first test

Big Horn Arabian 115/116/283 — merchant product photograph

Big Horn Arabian vs Antar: easier lifting or a leather seat to trial?

Dakota Roughout Cutter 101 — merchant product photograph

Dakota 101 vs Billy Cook 8940: roughout grip, seat tolerance and a model check

Hud Roberts Association 760H — merchant product photograph

Hud Roberts 760H vs Will James 62: fresh-leather feel or longer ownership history?

Dakota Roping 554 — merchant product photograph

Dakota 554 vs 420: choose the seat and fender setup before the weight

Billy Cook Barrel Racer 1530 — merchant listing product photograph

Billy Cook 1530 vs CJ 1550: compare the evidence, then the actual seat

Circle Y Kelly Kaminski Blaze 1528 — merchant listing product photograph

Circle Y Blaze 1528 vs Swift 1522: choose the seat and fenders before the lighter number

Fabtron Lady Trail 7152 / 7154 / 7156 saddle — merchant product photograph

Fabtron Lady Trail vs Supreme: does the quilted seat earn the upgrade?

Dakota 213 — listing product photograph

Dakota 213 vs 2212: compare seat depth, leg space and the written order

EXPLORE THE CATEGORIES

Find your riding style.

From quiet trail miles to a day in the arena.

All saddle reviews
Barrel racing saddles Around the next turn Endurance saddles For the miles ahead English saddles Dressage, jumping & all-purpose Ranch & roping saddles Explore working saddle styles Reining & training saddles Schooling & arena work Trail saddles Everyday trails & longer rides