Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

A considered choice.
A better ride.

Compare ⇄ ♡ Saved
  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

Circle Y

22 reviews from this brand
Circle Y Alabama 1581 review: comfort comes first, but inspect the equipment
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Alabama 1581

comfort comes first, but inspect the equipment

Read review ↗: Circle Y Alabama 1581
Circle Y Alpine 2377 review: deep-seat comfort with equipment to verify
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Alpine 2377

deep-seat comfort with equipment to verify

Read review ↗: Circle Y Alpine 2377
Circle Y Blaze 1528 review: a secure seat with a stirrup detail to inspect
Barrel Saddle

Circle Y Blaze 1528

a secure seat with a stirrup detail to inspect

Read review ↗: Circle Y Blaze 1528
Circle Y Cascade 1753 review: comfort depends on getting the girth right
Endurance Saddle

Circle Y Cascade 1753

comfort depends on getting the girth right

Read review ↗: Circle Y Cascade 1753
Circle Y Faith 1524 review: check both stirrup adjustments
Barrel Saddle

Circle Y Faith 1524

check both stirrup adjustments

Read review ↗: Circle Y Faith 1524
Circle Y Julie Goodnight Teton 1760 review: a balance-focused seat with a lower-cantle tradeoff
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Julie Goodnight Teton 1760

a balance-focused seat with a lower-cantle tradeoff

Read review ↗: Circle Y Julie Goodnight Teton 1760
Circle Y Kentucky 1582 review: a supportive pocket, with rear fittings to verify
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Kentucky 1582

a supportive pocket, with rear fittings to verify

Read review ↗: Circle Y Kentucky 1582
Circle Y Lady Trail 5701 review: try the twist before choosing the name
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Lady Trail 5701

try the twist before choosing the name

Read review ↗: Circle Y Lady Trail 5701
Circle Y Lolita 2651 review: all-around comfort with sunflower character
All Around Saddle

Circle Y Lolita 2651

all-around comfort with sunflower character

Read review ↗: Circle Y Lolita 2651
Circle Y Monarch 1752 review: arena-to-trail appeal, with pad movement to investigate
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Monarch 1752

arena-to-trail appeal, with pad movement to investigate

Read review ↗: Circle Y Monarch 1752
Circle Y Omaha 1554 review: choose the seat, then inspect the finish
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Omaha 1554

choose the seat, then inspect the finish

Read review ↗: Circle Y Omaha 1554
Circle Y Pioneer 1665 review: leg freedom without a guaranteed narrow twist
Trail Saddle

Circle Y Pioneer 1665

leg freedom without a guaranteed narrow twist

Read review ↗: Circle Y Pioneer 1665
Loading...

EXPLORE THE CATEGORIES

Find your riding style.

From quiet trail miles to a day in the arena.

All saddle reviews ↗
Barrel racing saddles Around the next turn ↗ Endurance saddles For the miles ahead ↗ English saddles Dressage, jumping & all-purpose ↗ Ranch & roping saddles Explore working saddle styles ↗ Reining & training saddles Schooling & arena work ↗ Trail saddles Everyday trails & longer rides ↗
Saddle CompassTHE RIDER’S EDIT

Thoughtful saddle research for the way you ride. Model details, owner perspectives and the questions worth asking before you buy.

Find your saddle

  • Saddle reviews
  • Best saddles
  • Comparisons
  • Riding guides

The fine print

  • About the project
  • Contact
  • Affiliate disclosure
  • Privacy policy
© 2026 Saddle Compass

Retailer links may earn us a commission. Owner reports are attributed experiences, not our riding tests.