THE SADDLE FILES / MODEL REVIEW
Circle Y Monarch 1752 review: arena-to-trail appeal, with pad movement to investigate
The Monarch’s clearest audience is a rider who wants Western equipment with a seat and leg position they can use in the arena and on trails. That appeal is supported by owner accounts; repeated reports of pad movement are the practical issue to settle during a trial.
In the saddle: at a glance
RIDER PRIORITIES / EQUIPMENT / OWNER EVIDENCE
KEY FEATURES
- Manufacturer identifies the 1752 Flex2 PP tree in Regular and Wide fits
- Impact Foam seat with narrow twist and broad pocket
- Slip-Not skirt liner with gel bar pad; 3-way adjustable in-skirt rigging
- Pre-twisted stirrup leathers and ErgoBalance stirrups; actual readiness varies in owner reports
YOUR RIDING PRIORITIES
- Consider it for
- Rider moving between arena work and trails, including riders transitioning from English or dressage saddles
- The tradeoff
- Pad slipping appears in multiple dated accounts; fender readiness and finish quality are inconsistent
- Before committing
- Assess the exact saddle and intended pad together. The Slip-Not name, pre-turned-stirrup description and another rider’s setup are not guarantees.
PROS
- Close seat and leg contact for arena work.
- Useful across arena training and trail outings.
- Can retain its appearance through regular use.
CONS
- Pads can slip beneath the saddle.
- Fenders and stirrups may need break-in.
- Substantial weight for lifting.
- Stitching and hardware need inspection.
- Seat contour and fender reach may not suit you.
Trail-saddle assessment
Research judgments · 5-point scale · Horse fit is not scored
Specific positive seat/contact accounts are qualified by contrary contour impressions.
Handling impressions vary and fender readiness is inconsistent.
A positive sustained-use account and dated defects do not establish current-edition durability.
Useful arena/trail setups coexist with recurring pad-movement reports.
How to read these bars
Editorial judgments from attributed owner accounts, not measured riding tests. Horse fit is not scored; historical editions and unspecified variants are included.
1: serious shortcomings; 2: drawbacks outweigh benefits; 3: mixed experience or setup tradeoffs; 4: repeated positives with caveats; 5: strong consistent evidence without a material unresolved limitation. Not rated means evidence is insufficient. These scores are not averaged into an overall star rating.
Read the original owner accountsWatch what moves in a Monarch trial
A March 2023 owner called the Monarch a favorite saddle to ride while reporting wool and felt pads sliding out behind it on two horses. Earlier accounts describe similar pad movement. This is an important qualification to the praise for its seat and leg contact.
| Account | Reported movement | Why the distinction matters |
|---|---|---|
| June 2014 | Pads and blankets slid out behind the saddle | Comfort praise coexisted with a persistent equipment problem |
| May and June 2018 | Owners liked the riding position but described pad movement | The arena-to-trail appeal did not remove the setup concern |
| March 2023 | Several wool/felt pads moved on two horses; owner later changed pad type | A reported personal outcome, not a prescribed replacement pad |
| March 2021 | The saddle itself slid forward | A separate observation from a pad slipping out behind |
Original Monarch owner accounts. The reports do not establish a single cause.
Some owners reported improvement after changing a pad or adding a liner. Their changes do not establish the cause in another setup. A fitting assessment needs to distinguish the pad moving from the saddle moving, rather than treating every report as the same problem.
The reason dressage riders keep appearing in the owner record
What these riders wanted from the position
- May 2018: a rider moving from dressage to Western dressage wanted close seat and leg contact.
- June 2018: an owner used the Monarch for both Western dressage and trails.
- December 2015: a rider liked having the leg beneath the hip instead of a chair-like position.
The manufacturer describes a narrow twist, a broad seat pocket and pre-twisted stirrup leathers on the 1752. Those features make a fitting trial worthwhile if you dislike being pushed into a chair-like position by another Western saddle. They do not demonstrate improved equitation or make the same seat suitable for every rider. Original owner accounts.
Ready to ride is not the same experience for every buyer
Inspect the supplied fenders and stirrups, including their usable adjustment range. “Pre-turned” does not describe every buyer’s experience.
How ready did the Monarch feel?
An easy start
A February 2020 owner praised the pre-turned stirrups and easy break-in. A November 2022 owner also found the saddle comfortable straight out of the box.
More work than expected
Accounts from 2012, 2018, 2021 and 2022 describe stirrups or fenders requiring more settling in than expected. Check the actual pair instead of assuming the label guarantees their feel.
There is a similar divide in finish history. A July 2021 parent reported three years of riding five days a week with the saddle still looking good. Other accounts name loose stitching, a failed tie-strap holder or an unspecified defective purchase. These histories make inspection useful; they cannot establish a current defect rate or a guaranteed service life.
Decide whether the position is worth the lift
Both the merchant and inspected manufacturer specification list 32 pounds. Some owners call the Monarch easy to handle relative to previous saddles; the parent who described three years of use called it a little heavy. If lifting is the problem you are trying to solve, its arena-to-trail versatility is a different benefit—not a reason to skip a handling trial.
For comparison, the Cashel Trail review considers a model listed around 24.5 pounds, but its owner fit and surface preferences need a separate assessment. The difference is useful for deciding what to lift in person; it does not establish which seat or tree will suit you.
Pros & Cons Analysis
Pros
- The Monarch can suit riders seeking a leg position underneath the hip and clear contact with the horse. Check pad stability separately from how the seat feels.
- Owners have used it for regular training, Western dressage and trail riding. Suitability for other work still depends on the task and exact setup.
- An older saddle remained attractive through sustained riding on one horse. Inspect a new purchase carefully, as other examples have had stitching or hardware problems.
Cons
- Some riders experience pad movement despite liking the seat. Assess the complete setup with a fitter; the Slip-Not label does not guarantee stability.
- Some pairs arrive stiff or less turned than expected, while others feel ready to ride. Check their actual orientation and flexibility before purchase.
- The listed 32 pounds can still feel heavy even to riders who like the saddle. Test it at your normal saddling height before choosing it to reduce effort.
- Reported problems include loose stitching and a failed tie-strap holder on earlier purchases. Check the exact saddle and confirm how defects would be handled.
- Padding can place some riders farther forward, and the seat may feel wider than expected. Test the full seated position and available fender adjustment.
The Monarch saddle-and-pad trial
Stability before commitment
Consider the Monarch for arena and trail work when close seat and leg contact are priorities. Try the intended saddle-and-pad combination.
Investigate pad movement with a fitter before committing, rather than treating repeated liner changes as the purchase plan.
Check the whole Monarch setup
Use these as reminders during your trial or seller conversation.
- Observe pad stability with the intended setup.
- Check seated position and available fender reach.
- Inspect stitching and hardware, then test the 32-pound lift.
Why pad stability comes first
The Monarch is a credible trial candidate for a rider who wants Western equipment for both arena work and trail days, especially when seat and leg contact are the main purchasing priorities. The recurring pad-movement reports make the intended saddle-and-pad combination an essential part of that trial. If it will not stay settled, seek a fit assessment rather than accepting a succession of improvised liners as the purchase plan. If the setup works, confirm the fender reach, inspect stitching and hardware, and make sure the 32-pound lift suits you before committing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Slip-Not liner guarantee that the pad will stay in place?
No. Multiple dated owner accounts report pads moving beneath the Monarch. Test the actual saddle and intended pad together, and have movement assessed instead of relying on the liner’s name.
Can the Monarch work for Western dressage and trail riding?
Owners describe using it for both, including riders transitioning from English or dressage saddles. That supports a fitting trial for those purposes, not a promise that its position will suit every rider or improve performance.
Are the Monarch stirrups ready to ride without break-in?
The manufacturer describes pre-twisted leathers, and some owners were pleased immediately. Other owners report more stiffness or turning than expected. Inspect the offered saddle’s fenders and stirrups before assuming the same experience.
Technical Specifications
| Model / scope | Julie Goodnight Monarch 1752; exact offered configuration to confirm Manufacturer |
|---|---|
| Intended use | Trail and arena use described; no universal discipline approval Manufacturer |
| Seat sizes | 14, 15, 15.5, 16, 17 in Manufacturer |
| Seat construction | Impact Foam; manufacturer describes narrow twist and broad pocket Manufacturer |
| Cantle height | 3.5 in Manufacturer |
| Tree construction | Flex2 PP Manufacturer |
| Tree / bar options | Regular, Wide Manufacturer |
| Published gullet width | Not verified for the exact offered configuration |
| Main materials | Softee leather jockeys/fenders; Slip-Not liner with gel bar pad Manufacturer |
| Rigging | 3-way adjustable in-skirt Manufacturer |
| Skirt length | 27 in Manufacturer |
| Skirt drop | 15 in Manufacturer |
| Swell width | 13 in Manufacturer |
| Horn dimensions / type | Height 2.25 in; cap conflict: merchant 2.25 in, manufacturer 3 in Merchant; Manufacturer |
| Published saddle weight | 32 lb in both product sources; added gear not included by assumption Manufacturer |
| Hardware | Silver on silver Manufacturer |
| Included equipment | Manufacturer describes ErgoBalance stirrups and six strings; complete cinch/tie package to confirm Manufacturer |
ALL CATEGORIES
Find your riding style.
Explore saddle categories for the way you and your horse ride.
